The $6 billion Airwallex lesson: why value creation happens before you can access it

The contrast is stark - while pre-seed investors in Airwallex could see >1000x returns, late-stage investors are hoping for "just" 2-3x after IPO, revealing how early value creation happens in private markets.
Written by
Sam Henderson
Operating Partner

When Airwallex announced its $US300 million Series F round last month, valuing the payments company at $US6.2 billion, Blackbird partner Michael Tolo made an unusually candid admission.

"We absolutely made a mistake not investing earlier," he said. "And it's the most expensive one that we have made at Blackbird."

His admission reveals a systemic shift affecting all investors. When billion-dollar growth funds find themselves paying premium valuations for late-stage deals, it demonstrates how the traditional playbook - wait for proven success, then invest - now captures only the tail end of value creation.

The maths of early-stage value creation

Consider Airwallex's journey from different investor perspectives:

  • Pre-seed investors (hypothetical $5 million valuation): 1,240x returns
  • Seed investors (hypothetical $20 million valuation): 310x returns
  • Series A investors (estimated $100 million valuation): 62x returns
  • Series F investors (current $6.2 billion valuation): Hoping for 2-3x after IPO

Even if Blackbird doubles their money from the Series F, they're capturing perhaps 0.2% of the value that pre-seed investors secured. This perfectly illustrates how venture returns follow a power law distribution - the earlier you invest, the more exponential the potential returns.

Compare this to Canva, where Blackbird invested $250,000 in the company's $3 million seed round in 2013 and participated in its entire value creation journey to a $50 billion private valuation.

Why traditional portfolios miss the wealth creation window

Individual sophisticated investors face the same structural challenge:

  • Too early to evaluate: Most can't assess pre-revenue companies with confidence
  • Too late to access: By the time potential becomes obvious, they're competing with institutional money at mature valuations

According to PitchBook data, companies now stay private 2.5 times longer than they did in the 1990s. This means the rapid growth phase – where a $5 million company becomes a $5 billion company – happens entirely in private markets.

Traditional portfolios, regardless of sophistication, simply cannot access these opportunities during their wealth creation phase. This is precisely why the timing question isn't what most investors think - you're not too late, you're just looking in the wrong places.

How early-stage venture capital captures transformative growth

Professional early-stage venture capital funds are designed specifically for this challenge. They invest in 20-50 companies during their highest-risk, highest-reward phase, understanding that exceptional returns from winners more than compensate for inevitable failures.

Cambridge Associates research demonstrates this "power law" effect has consistently delivered 25-35% annual returns for top quartile early-stage funds over two decades. As we explore in our analysis of seed-stage performance, the numbers are compelling:

  • Pre-seed funds target 10x-100x returns on their best investments
  • Growth-stage funds typically aim for 3x-5x returns
  • It's exponentially easier to grow from $5 million to $500 million than from $1 billion to $5 billion

However, these top-tier returns highlight the critical importance of fund selection. The gap between top-quartile and bottom-quartile performance in venture capital is wider than in almost any other asset class, making manager due diligence paramount.

The institutional trend towards private markets

This opportunity hasn't gone unnoticed by large institutional investors. AustralianSuper, the country's largest super fund, has direct investments in several Australian VC funds.

University endowments like Yale and Harvard have allocated 20-30% of their portfolios to venture capital and private equity, achieving returns that traditional asset allocation simply cannot match.

If institutions are moving capital to private markets for superior returns, what does that mean for sophisticated individual investors still relying entirely on public market exposure? Understanding where venture capital fits in your broader portfolio becomes crucial for maintaining competitive returns.

Understanding the trade-offs

Early-stage venture capital requires accepting different characteristics than public market investing:

  • Higher risk: Many pre-seed companies will fail completely
  • Longer timeframes: Value creation happens over 7-10 years
  • Greater concentration: Returns are driven by a small number of exceptional outcomes
  • Illiquidity: Capital is typically locked up for the fund's lifetime

But for suitable investors, these trade-offs unlock access to returns that traditional asset classes simply cannot provide. Professional fund management becomes a significant advantage, as early-stage funds provide hands-on operational support to help portfolio companies navigate their highest-risk, highest-growth phase.

When public markets finally get access, growth is largely complete

When Airwallex eventually goes public, individual investors will finally have the opportunity to own shares. But they'll be purchasing a mature, established business valued at billions rather than participating in the foundational value creation that generated exponential returns for private investors.

The critical insight isn't that public markets are poor investments. It's that modern wealth creation increasingly happens in private markets first. By the time companies reach public exchanges, their most dramatic growth phases are largely behind them.

For sophisticated investors, the question isn't whether they can afford to invest in early-stage venture capital. It's whether they can afford to remain entirely disconnected from where modern innovation creates transformational wealth.

Heading 1

Heading 2

Heading 3

Heading 4

Heading 5
Heading 6

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipiscing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore magna aliqua. Ut enim ad minim veniam, quis nostrud exercitation ullamco laboris nisi ut aliquip ex ea commodo consequat. Duis aute irure dolor in reprehenderit in voluptate velit esse cillum dolore eu fugiat nulla pariatur.

Block quote

Ordered list

  1. Item 1
  2. Item 2
  3. Item 3

Unordered list

  • Item A
  • Item B
  • Item C

Text link

Bold text

Emphasis

Superscript

Subscript

Disclaimer

This article is for informational purposes only and does not constitute financial advice or an offer to invest. Investments in venture capital carry significant risks and are suitable only for sophisticated investors. For more information, please request our Information Memorandum. This offer is not available to retail investors.

No items found.

What's in the calendar

See All
Soon
Past events
Melbourne
April 11, 2024
17:30
-
19:30
Skalata x OIF Ventures Founder Drinks

The OIF Ventures team is in town from Sydney, and we thought it would be a perfect opportunity to join forces for a night of networking and conversation.

Register now
Soon
Past events
Sunshine Coast
April 11, 2024
6:30
-
10:30
Yoga, Surf, Network

Skalata, Cake Equity and River City Labs are teaming up to host an energising morning of Sunrise Yoga, Surf kicking off at 6.30am at Maroochydore Beach followed by a rooftop breakfast at Ocean City Labs.

Register now
Soon
Past events
Sunshine Coast
April 11, 2024
6:30
-
10:30
Yoga, Surf, Network

Skalata, Cake Equity and River City Labs are teaming up to host an energising morning of Sunrise Yoga, Surf kicking off at 6.30am at Maroochydore Beach followed by a rooftop breakfast at Ocean City Labs.

Register now
Soon
Past events
Melbourne
April 11, 2024
17:30
-
19:30
Skalata x OIF Ventures Founder Drinks

The OIF Ventures team is in town from Sydney, and we thought it would be a perfect opportunity to join forces for a night of networking and conversation.

Register now
See All